Not long ago, my wife had an interesting experience at work. She is a school teacher, so she’s used to ‘interesting experiences’, but this one stuck out to her in a way more tragic than usual. Her group of fourth graders had been learning about what a ‘career’ is, and what kinds of possibilities await them once they’ve finished the educational portion of their upbringing.
Of course children are aware of what a career-type job might be; you’d be hard-pressed to find a child who is unaware of what a firefighter or an astronaut is. That’s part of the beauty of being a child - the ability and the freedom to employ the imagination to make our lives what we want (if only for a few glorious minutes of a daydream). We all know that the ability to imagine has led to many incredible feats of humanity in the real world. The imagination and the aspirations of children have truly gone on to change this world for the better.
Did we not all have grade school classmates who told us that they would someday be President of the United States? Or the first person to fly to Mars? Or the owner of a fashion design company? Or a famous scientist or author?
Did we not all personally aspire to high achievements in this world, whether we openly admitted them or not? As we grew older, we realized that the odds of becoming one of the few people to walk the moon were not in our favor, but we still maintained high hopes for ourselves and our families. As the saying goes, ‘we aimed for the moon, and though we missed, we still landed among the stars.’ As it turns out, that’s also a pretty good place to be. In short, one might call this the American Dream.
The detractors would tell you that the american dream is all about crushing the masses in order to enter the high society, but isn’t it just about turning dreams into reality? Wasn’t the original american dream simply referring to one’s ability to achieve dreams, in America - the place focused on the individual’s freedom to achieve dreams?
We might reasonably argue that the aspirations of an empire’s rising generation is an honest blueprint for the future of that empire. The tragedy here is that the american dream and the high-flying aspirations of the past are no longer welcome in the hearts of most of the rising generation. When prompted about their future career dreams, my wife’s group of fourth graders responded with answers such as “pizza delivery guy,” “the drive-through guy at McDonald’s,” “a janitor” and “nothing…” among other heartbreakers. The single exception was a lone student who responded with "President of the United States" - promptly scoffed and laughed at by classmates. What child answers this defining question with “nothing”??? Is it that they now know that “nothing” is an acceptable response, or do they honestly want to do and be “nothing” when they grow up?
Truth be told, I’ve personally spent many long hours behind the counters of different burger and pizza shops, as have my cohorts - the cardinal difference is that we understood that these jobs are stepping-stones, not destinations, that will help us to reach the places that we aspired to as fourth graders. The current propaganda surrounding these stepping-stone jobs is all about getting a “living wage” for minimum wage jobs. This tells us that these can be destination jobs, and that there’s no reason to look up, beyond the fryers and cash registers, for a brighter hope.
Within a decade, these fourth-graders will be reaching the prime of life. Can this nation survive a generation so low on aspiration, hope and desire? Technical competence aside (US students currently rank 20th in reading, 23rd in science and 30th in mathematics worldwide, as per NPR), can our children find the emotional fortitude required to conquer the hills and mountains that our predecessors climbed? Will this really be the first generation with a standard of living worse than their parents, as the analysts predict? Only time will tell, but we at least know that we need to strengthen their hearts too, not just their brains.